Psychology Bulletin2013-09-05 2:57 AM

The hundred-year emotion war: Are emotions natural kinds or psychological constructions? Comment on Lench, Flores, and Bench

Abstract For the last century, there has been a continuing debate about the nature of emotion. In the most recent offering in this scientific dialogue, Lench, Flores, and Bench (2011) reported a meta-analysis of emotion induction research and claimed support for the natural kind hypothesis that discrete emotions (e.g., happiness, sadness, anger, and anxiety) elicit specific changes in cognition, judgment, behavior, experience, and physiology. In this article, we point out that Lench et al. (2011) is not the final word on the emotion debate. First, we point out that Lench et al.'s findings do not support their claim that discrete emotions organize cognition, judgment, experience, and physiology because they did not demonstrate emotion-consistent and emotion-specific directional changes in these measurement domains. Second, we point out that Lench et al.'s findings are in fact consistent with the alternative (a psychological constructionist approach to emotion). We close by appealing for a construct validity approach to emotion research, which we hope will lead to greater consensus on the operationalization of the natural kind and psychological construction approaches, as well as the criteria required to finally resolve the emotion debate. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2013 APA, all rights reserved)

KEYWORDS

SHARE & LIKE

COMMENTS

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Psychology Bulletin

Psychological Bulletin is a bimonthly peer-reviewed academic journal that publishes evaluative and integrative research reviews and interpretations of issues in psychology, including both qualitative (narrative) and/or quantitative (meta-analytic) aspects.

0 Following 8 Fans 0 Projects 52 Articles

SIMILAR ARTICLES

Emotion expression is an important feature of healthy child development that has been found to show gender differences. However, there has been no empi

Read More

Emotion expression is an important feature of healthy child development that has been found to show gender differences. However, there has been no empi

Read More

The term statistical learning in infancy research originally referred to sensitivity to transitional probabilities. Subsequent research has demonstrate

Read More

The term statistical learning in infancy research originally referred to sensitivity to transitional probabilities. Subsequent research has demonstrate

Read More

Abstract Previous research has clearly established associations between low socioeconomic status (SES) and poor youth physical health outcomes. This a

Read More

Abstract Previous research has clearly established associations between low socioeconomic status (SES) and poor youth physical health outcomes. This a

Read More

Abstract Disgust has been theorized to be a basic emotion with a facial signal that is easily, universally, automatically, and perhaps innately recogn

Read More

Abstract Disgust has been theorized to be a basic emotion with a facial signal that is easily, universally, automatically, and perhaps innately recogn

Read More

Abstract Pretend play has been claimed to be crucial to children's healthy development. Here we examine evidence for this position versus 2 alternativ

Read More

Abstract Pretend play has been claimed to be crucial to children's healthy development. Here we examine evidence for this position versus 2 alternativ

Read More