Kal Raustiala 2014-03-07 6:06 PM

传统知识中有关案例知识产权的不稳定案例 The Uneasy Case for Intellectual Property Rights in Traditional Knowledge

Abstract
Should traditional knowledge - the understanding or skill possessed by indigenous peoples pertaining to their culture and folklore and their use of native plants for medicinal purposes - receive protection as intellectual property? This Article examines nine major arguments from the moral, political and legal philosophy of property for intellectual property rights and contends that, as applied to traditional knowledge (TK), they justify at most a modest package of rights under domestic and international law. The arguments involve desert based on labor; firstness; stewardship; stability; moral right of the community; incentives to innovate; incentives to commercialize; unjust enrichment, misappropriation and restitution; and infringement and dilution. These arguments do, however, support “defensive” protection for TK: that is, halting the use of TK by nonindigenous actors in obtaining patents and copyrights. These arguments also support the dissemination of TK on the internet and via other digital media and the selective use of trademarks. The force of these conclusions resides in the importance of a vibrant public domain, and the absence of any plausible limiting principle that would allow more robust rights in TK for indigenous groups without permitting equally robust rights for nonindigenous groups.

KEYWORDS

SHARE & LIKE

COMMENTS

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Kal Raustiala

0 Following 1 Fans 0 Projects 8 Articles

SIMILAR ARTICLES

论文摘要自从二次世界大战灾难以来,国际秩序已经变得越来越制度化。数以百计的国际组织和数以万计的条约现存于世,且许多其中组织所拥有的成员分布广泛甚至遍布全球。较之过去时代,当今国际体系的规则和制度更为完善缜密。下一段落探索了机构密度,冲突和竞争,这种密度不可避免地会导致产生国家无政府体系以及国际律师和政

Read More

Abstract    One of the signal features of contemporary world politics is that intellectual property rights are increasingly an arena for global coopera

Read More

AbstractThe WTO TRIPs Agreement heralded a landmark and controversial change in international law. It significantly increased the power of internationa

Read More

Abstract   This paper, written for a forthcoming volume on climate change, provides a positive analysis of the roles and impact of non-state actors (NG

Read More

AbstractShould traditional knowledge - the understanding or skill possessed by indigenous peoples pertaining to their culture and folklore and their us

Read More

AbstractThis essay, forthcoming in the Oxford Guide to Treaties, surveys the role of NGOs in treatymaking. It asks four key questions. First, what role

Read More

Abstract  The orthodox justification for intellectual property is utilitarian. Advocates for strong IP rights argue that absent such rights copyists wi

Read More

AbstractJack Goldsmith and Eric Posner's "The Limits of International Law" is not an uplifting read for most international lawyers, who are trained to

Read More