JIJITANG2014-07-24 4:25 PM

DO MEDICAID RULES SEND PEOPLE TO PRISON?

People with schizophrenia are more likely to end up in prison in states with tight Medicaid policies governing antipsychotic drugs, research shows.

The new study comes amid media scrutiny over whether cutbacks in mental health actually save money when other costs are taken into account.

Some health plans require an extra approval step before tests or treatments can be ordered for patients. This step—called prior authorization—is intended to encourage physicians to select cost-effective options by requiring justification for the selection of more expensive options.

Likewise, prior authorization policies adopted by state Medicaid programs aim to reduce costs associated with some medications, especially those drugs used to treat schizophrenia.

However, an unintended consequence of these policies may be that more mentally-ill patients are being incarcerated, raising questions about the “cost-effectiveness” of these formulary restrictions.

PENNY WISE, POUND FOOLISH

Published in the American Journal of Managed Care, the study reports that states requiring prior authorization for atypical antipsychotics had less serious mental illness overall but higher shares of inmates with psychotic symptoms than the national average.

The study concludes that prior authorization of atypical antipsychotics was associated with a 22 percent increase in the likelihood of imprisonment, compared with the likelihood in a state without such a requirement.

“This paper demonstrates that our policies around schizophrenia may be penny wise and pound foolish,” says Dana Goldman, director of the Leonard D. Schaeffer Center for Health Policy & Economics at the University of Southern California.

“Limiting access to effective therapy may save states some Medicaid money in the short run, but the downstream consequences—including more people in prisons and more criminal activity—could be a bad deal for society.”

TROUBLING CONCERNS

The study examined survey data from 16,844 prison inmates in states with and without restrictive authorization requirements overlaid with state Medicaid policies and data as well as usage rates of atypical antipsychotics (a newer drug class that is frequently targeted by prior authorization requirements).

The study’s findings come amid a wave of scrutiny surrounding the cost and consequences of failing to adequately provide for mental health care, including the nexus between shortchanging mental health and rising prison expenditures.

“The media has picked up on how incarcerating the mentally ill raises a range of troubling concerns, from the high cost of incarceration, to the inadequate treatment of mentally ill inmates, and the potential for self-inflicted harm among these patients,” says Darius Lakdawalla, professor and chair of pharmaceutical development and regulatory innovation.

“At the same time, the American public is increasingly worried about untreated mental illness triggering violent behavior in the community. Our study suggests state Medicaid policies may be part of the solution to these problems.”

Original Article: 
《Medicaid Prior Authorization Policies and Imprisonment Among Patients With Schizophrenia》, Published on Journal 《AJMC》in July 21, 2014. 

KEYWORDS

SHARE & LIKE

COMMENTS

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

JIJITANG

0 Following 3 Fans 0 Projects 310 Articles

SIMILAR ARTICLES

Changes to the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) have resulted in families eating more fruits and vegetable

Read More

In contests drawn from game theory, chimpanzee pairs consistently outperform humans in games that test memory and strategic thinking.A new study, condu

Read More

Publishing is one of the most ballyhooed metrics of scientific careers, and every researcher hates to have a gap in that part of his or her CV. Here’s

Read More

Pornography triggers brain activity in people with compulsive sexual behaviour -- known commonly as sex addiction -- similar to that triggered by drugs

Read More

In a recent survey, academic staff at the University identified the interrelated skills of writing and reasoning as the two most important skills for s

Read More

In a recent survey, academic staff at the University identified the interrelated skills of writing and reasoning as the two most important skills for s

Read More

Reading cautionary tales like The Boy Who Cried Wolf and Pinocchio to little kids might not be the best way to teach them to tell the truth.New researc

Read More

Those flat, glassy solar panels on your neighbor’s roof may be getting a more efficient makeover, thanks to a new class of solar-sensitive nanoparticle

Read More

Physicists have overcome a major challenge in the science of measurement using quantum mechanics. They’ve used multiple detectors to measure photons in

Read More

If you want to slow down long enough to smell the proverbial roses, you might want to move to a neighborhood with fewer drive-thru restaurants, researc

Read More