Harvard Business School2014-08-26 4:04 PM

The (Perceived) Meaning of Spontaneous Thoughts

Abstract

Spontaneous thoughts, the output of a broad category of uncontrolled and inaccessible higher-order mental processes, arise frequently in everyday life. The seeming randomness by which spontaneous thoughts arise might give people good reason to dismiss them as meaningless. We suggest that it is precisely the lack of control over and access to the processes by which they arise that leads people to perceive spontaneous thoughts to reveal meaningful self-insight. Consequently, spontaneous thoughts potently influence judgment. A series of experiments provides evidence supporting two hypotheses. First, we hypothesize that the more a thought is perceived to be spontaneous, the more it is perceived to provide meaningful self-insight. Participants perceived more spontaneous kinds of thought to reveal greater self-insight than more controlled kinds of thought in Study 1 (e.g., intuition versus deliberation), and perceived thoughts with the same content and target to reveal greater self-insight when spontaneously than deliberately generated in Studies 2 and 3 (i.e., childhood memories and impressions formed, respectively). Second, we hypothesize that greater self-insight attributed to thoughts that are (perceived to be) spontaneous leads those thoughts to more potently influence judgment. Participants felt more sexually attracted to an attractive person whom they thought of spontaneously than deliberately in Study 4, and reported their commitment to a current romantic relationship would be more affected by the spontaneous than deliberate recollection of a good or bad experience with their partner in Study 5.

 

Much human thought arises unbidden, spontaneously intruding upon consciousness. The thought and name of a former lover might come to mind during dinner with one's spouse. Or worse, it may be blurted out during an intimate moment. Because no trace of the past lover is present, the thought lacks an apparent cause. In the latter case it almost certainly occurs without intent, given its potential consequences. The seeming randomness of such thoughts might provide reason to dismiss them as the wanderings of a restless mind. We propose that it is precisely the lack of control over and access to the process by which spontaneous thoughts come to mind that leads them to be perceived to reveal special self-insight. Drawing on previous theory and research, we propose that the greater self-insight they are attributed leads spontaneous thoughts to exert a greater impact on attitudes and behavior than similar deliberate thoughts. 

 

Compare a wife's thought of a former lover while perusing her yearbook to that same thought during an intimate moment with her husband. In the former case, the reason for the production of that thought is clear ("I thought of him because I looked at his picture while reminiscing about the past"). In the latter case, she lacks both control over the thought and access to its origin. We suggest that its apparent spontaneity should lead her to attribute it special meaning ("Why would I think of him in this moment unless it is important?"), and it should consequently exert a greater influence on her judgment ("I must still have feelings for him"). In this paper, we report a series of five studies examining how the perceived spontaneity of thought influences the extent to which it is believed to yield meaningful self-insight and influences judgment.

 

Full Article

Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 143, no. 4 (August 2014): 1742–1754

http://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/item.aspx?num=47179

KEYWORDS

SHARE & LIKE

COMMENTS

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Harvard Business School

哈佛商学院是世界最著名的商学院之一,是常春藤联盟商学院之一,早先名为”哈佛大学工商管理研究所“。美国教育界有这么一个说法:哈佛大学可算是全美所有大学中的一项王冠,而王冠上那夺人眼目的宝珠,就是哈佛商学院。哈佛商学院的名望,不仅是由于她首创了MBA学位,也不仅是因为她在管理教学中首创了案例教学法,还不仅是基于她拥有一个庞大的明星教授群,而是因为她确确实实向社会输送了大批极其优秀的人才。正是这些毕业生在社会上的卓越表现,才使哈佛商学院扬名世界。

0 Following 6 Fans 0 Projects 17 Articles

SIMILAR ARTICLES

AuthorNava Ashraf, Erica Field and Jean LeeAbstractWe posit that household decision-making over fertility is characterized by moral hazard due to the f

Read More

AuthorLynn S. PaineAbstractOne surprising role of Nike’s corporate responsibility committee is to provide support for innovation. More and more compani

Read More

AuthorEugene F. Soltes, David H. Solomon and Denis SosyuraAbstractWe show that media coverage of mutual fund holdings affects how investors allocate mo

Read More

AuthorSilvia Bellezza and Anat KeinanAbstractThe article discusses how exclusive brands can increase their sales by moving "downmarket" without diminis

Read More

AuthorMax BazermanAbstractWe'd like to think that no smart, upstanding manager would ever overlook or turn a blind eye to threats or wrongdoing that ul

Read More

AuthorRobert C. MertonAbstractCorporate America began to really take notice of the looming retirement crisis in the wake of the dot-com crash, when com

Read More

AuthorRanjay Gulati, Charles Casto and Charlotte KrontirisAbstractIn March 2011, Japan’s Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant was devastated by three

Read More

AuthorAnita ElberseAbstractMarkets for soccer players are winner-take-all markets in which a select few top players earn extremely high rewards. The se

Read More

AuthorJill Avery, Susan Fournier and John WittenbrakerAbstractConsumers have always had relationships with brands, but sophisticated tools for analyzin

Read More

AbstractWe conduct and analyze two large surveys of hypothetical annuitization choices. We find that allowing individuals to annuitize a fraction of th

Read More