Journal of Political Economy2014-10-22 6:14 PM

Crime and the Depenalization of Cannabis Possession: Evidence from a Policing Experiment

Abstract 

We evaluate the impact on crime of a localized policing experiment that depenalized the possession of small quantities of cannabis in the London borough of Lambeth. Such a policy can: (i) impact the demand for cannabis in Lambeth as users move there to purchase cannabis; (ii) enable the Lambeth police to reallocate effort towards other types of crime. We investigate whether the depenalization policy impacts the level and composition of crime, using administrative records on criminal offences by drug type, and for seven types of nondrug crime. We find that depenalization in Lambeth led to significant increases in cannabis possession offences that persisted well after the policy experiment ended. We find evidence that the policy caused the police to reallocate effort towards crimes related to the supply of Class-A drugs, as well as reallocating effort towards non-drug crime: there are significant reductions in five types of non-drug crime, and significant improvements in police effectiveness against such crimes as measured by arrest and clear-up rates. Despite the overall fall in crime attributable to the policy, we find the total welfare of local residents likely fell, as measured by house prices. These welfare losses are concentrated in Lambeth zip codes where the illicit drug market was most active. Finally, we shed light on what would be the impacts on crime of a citywide depenalization policy, by developing and calibrating a structural model of the market for cannabis and crime, accounting for the behavior of police and cannabis users. This highlights that many of the gains of the policy can be retained, and some of the deleterious consequences ameliorated, if all jurisdictions depenalized cannabis possession. These results provide new insights for the current policy debate on the regulation of illicit drug markets.

Keywords: police behavior, cannabis, crime, depenalization


Full Article

KEYWORDS

SHARE & LIKE

COMMENTS

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Journal of Political Economy

One of the oldest and most prestigious journals in economics, the Journal of Political Economy has since 1892 presented significant research and scholarship in economic theory and practice.

0 Following 5 Fans 0 Projects 12 Articles

SIMILAR ARTICLES

AbstractWe model intergroup conflict driven by economic changes within groups. We show that if group incomes are low, increasing group incomes raises v

Read More

AbstractThe paper presents a positive model of policy formation in federal legislatures when delegates engage in the strategic exchange of policy-relev

Read More

AbstractWe study the wealth accumulation of Indian state politicians using public disclosures required of all candidates. The annual asset growth of wi

Read More

AbstractInvestment of US firms responds asymmetrically to Tobin’s Q: investment of established firms—“intensive” investment—reacts negatively to Q wher

Read More

AbstractThis paper considers when a firm’s deliberately chosen name can signal meaningful information. The average plumbing firm whose name begins with

Read More

Abstract We study a novel mechanism design model in which agents each arrive sequentially and choose one action from a set of actions with unknown rewa

Read More

Abstract We investigate the role of dynamic production inputs and their associated adjustment costs in shaping the dispersion of static measures of cap

Read More

Abstract Cities are neither completely specialized nor completely diverse. However, prior research has focused almost entirely on the polar cases of co

Read More

Abstract We study mechanism design in a context where communicational constrains prevent the use of revelation mechanisms, and agents behave strategica

Read More

Abstract We evaluate the impact on crime of a localized policing experiment that depenalized the possession of small quantities of cannabis in the Lond

Read More