Academy of Management Review2014-11-08 2:24 PM

Organizational Theories: Some Criteria for Evaluation

Abstract

A set of ground rules and vocabulary to facilitate focused discussion about the structure of organization and management theories are proposed. The many previous efforts at defining and evaluating theory help establish criteria for theory construction and evaluation. In the establishment of these criteria, description is distinguished from theory, and a matrix of criteria for evaluating the variables, constructs, and relationships that together compose a theory is developed. The proposed matrix may be useful both for defining the necessary components of good theory and for evaluating and/or comparing the quality of alternative theories. Finally, a discussion of the way theories fit together to give a somewhat broader picture of empirical reality reveals the lines of tension between the two main criteria for evaluating theory.


Full Article

KEYWORDS

SHARE & LIKE

COMMENTS

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Academy of Management Review

The Academy of Management Review (AMR) is ranked among the top five most influential and frequently cited management and business journals. AMR is a theory development journal that publishes the highest quality conceptual work. Impact Factor: 7.817.

0 Following 10 Fans 0 Projects 71 Articles

SIMILAR ARTICLES

AbstractThis article applies the convergent insights of institutional and resource dependence perspectives to the prediction of strategic responses to

Read More

AbstractThe complexity of political, regulatory, and technological changes confronting most organizations has made radical organizational change and ad

Read More

AbstractThis paper describes the process of inducting theory using case studies—from specifying the research questions to reaching closure. Some featur

Read More

AbstractManagement scholars have long separated the study of work and diversity, assuming that the nature of work itself is not affected by race or gen

Read More

AbstractWe argue that under certain circumstances crowdsourcing transforms distant search into local search, improving the efficiency and effectiveness

Read More

Impact Factor: 7.817#1 of 172 journals in the category of "Management." #1 of 110 journals in the category of "Business."*2013 Journal Citation Reports

Read More

AbstractWe investigate the organizational pursuit of seemingly impossible goals—commonly known as stretch goals. Building from our analysis of the mech

Read More

AbstractWhat happens when an employee generates a new idea and wants to further explore it but is instructed by a manager to stop working on it? Among

Read More

AbstractWe create a taxonomy of hybrid governance forms and develop a formal theory that predicts when a given hybrid form will be efficient. Our model

Read More

AbstractWe define management innovation as the invention and implementation of a management practice, process, structure, or technique that is new to t

Read More